There can be little argument that Peyton Manning, should he retire tomorrow, would be a first-ballot inductee into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. His skill and prowess at the quarterback position are legendary, and he has a Super Bowl victory on his resumé. Yet, in a season where he was winning a second world championship while Peyton never set foot on the field, most fans would still say that Eli Manning has not eclipsed the accomplishments of his older brother.
One can make the argument that winning a Super Bowl helps a quarterback’s chances of making the Pro Football Hall of Fame, of which there’s no denying. But, conversely, it certainly helps your team’s chances to win a Super Bowl if y... Read Post
Based on regular season play, Peyton Manning is a Hall of Fame quarterback. Based on postseason play, Eli Manning is a Hall of Fame quarterback. For the brothers, it is a strange tale of opposites, but both have earned their elite s... Read Post
If Eli Manning were to retire right now, would he be considered a Hall of Fame quarterback? No, however, he is very close and it is most definitely reasonable to argue that Eli is deserving of pro football immortality. But, a second... Read Post