Post Profile

Who's On (The) Second (Circuit)... And Why Are They Screwing Up Copyright Law?

So, last year, we wrote about the ridiculous situation in which the heirs of Abbott and Costello had sued for copyright infringement over a broadway play, Hand to God. In that play, which is a dark drama, and not a comedy, about a puppeteer, there's a scene in which the puppeteer performs a bit of the famous "Who's On First?" routine with puppets. The district court wasted little time in dumping the lawsuit.
read more


Related Posts

Abbott & Costello Heirs Sue Play For Briefly Using 'Who's On First?' Routine

Industries / Law : Techdirt

Abbott & Costello's Who's on First? routine is one of the most well-known comedy bits of the 20th century. There are a bunch of different variations on it, and they often changed things around when they performed it. Here's one famo...

Another Fair Use Debacle: Photographer Settles Bogus Copyright Threat From Artist

Industries / Law : Techdirt

Last year, we wrote about the absolutely ridiculous situation in which an artist, Jack Mackie, sued a photographer, Mike Hipple, for copyright infringement. The details of the case were pretty crazy. Mackie had created a piece of pu...

Abbott & Costello Heirs Sue Tony Nominee ‘Hand To God’ Over ‘Who’s On First?’

Industries / Entertainment Industry : Deadline Hollywood

Sex between consenting puppets may be fine on a Broadway stage, but lifting one of comedy’s most famous routines may be going too far. A lawsuit filed this week in the Southern District of New York claims copyright infringement agai...

Copyright Lawsuit Over 'Who's On First' Doesn't Get Past First Base

Industries / Law : Techdirt

Earlier this year, we wrote about (yet another) ridiculous copyright lawsuit where the heirs of famous people think they must own something just because everything must be "owned." In this case, it was the heirs of Abbott & Costello...

A dreaded sunny day for Abbott & Costello heirs: play made fair use of Who's On First

Industries / Law : 43(B)log

TCA Television Corp. v. McCollum, No. 15 Civ. 4325 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 17, 2105) The “critically-acclaimed Broadway dark comedy, Hand to God,” used dialogue from the iconic comedy routine, Who’s On First?both in the play and in a promoti...


Copyright © 2016 Regator, LLC