Post Profile

Angus Menuge responds to Keith Parsons

This part is incomprehensible to me: It is not the abstract propositional content of, say, the statement of modus tollens that constrains or compels me to reason in accordance with that rule, but rather my physical act of recognition that modus tollens is a valid argument form that, in complex combination with other causal factors and conditions, determines my conclusion in accordance with that rule.
read more


Related Posts

Angus Menuge on the argument from reason

Academics / Philosophy : Dangerous Idea

Here. Wintery Knight has put together some resources.

The Religion of Archeological Preservation

Academics / Philosophy : Maverick Philosopher

If Islam is the religion of peace, then it is also the religion of archeological preservation. Modus tollens or modus ponens?

Angus Menuge develops Puddleglum's argument a different way

Academics / Philosophy : Dangerous Idea

A redated post.In Bassham and Walls ed. The Chronicles of Narnia and Philosophy (Open Court, 2005), Angus Menuge finds an implicit argument against materialism that is not pragmatic in nature. In "Why Eustace Almost Deserved His Nam...

'Whose' and 'Of Which': How Punctilious is Too Punctilious?

Academics / Philosophy : Maverick Philosopher

Which of the following is correct? 'He presented an argument whose logical form is Modus Tollens.' 'He presented an argument the logical form of which is Modus Tollens.' The second. But it would be absurd to insist on a punctilio...

More dialogue with Keith Parsons

Academics / Philosophy : Dangerous Idea

KP: My claim is that the realization (cognitive sense) of, say, the cogency of Draper's argument, is realized (non-cognitive sense) in the physical operation of my brain. Indeed, I am saying that the mental act of recognizing the co...


Copyright © 2016 Regator, LLC